State Supreme Court issues disappointing ruling in agricultural overtime case

The Washington State Supreme Court issued a disappointing ruling effectively striking down our state’s exemption from paying dairy farmworkers time-and-a-half for overtime.

While we believe the court erred in its opinion, this case involves a state constitutional question, and there is no venue to appeal it beyond the state Supreme Court.

The lengthy ruling can be found here

Our advice is for dairy farmers to begin paying workers time-and-a-half for overtime immediately. This legal memo from Stephanie Berntsen at Schwabe Williamson & Wyatt answers many questions about how the court’s opinion should be applied. Please review this document and implement these suggestions. 

More details of the case and opinion are given in this article from the Capital Press.

Gov. Inslee Orders New Regulations for Ag Worker Safety – Effective June 4

Agricultural employers, including dairies, must take immediate action to put in place new directives from the state government. Key things employers will need to do include the following:

  • Provide PPE to employees
  • Require employees to wear masks when not working alone
  • Ensure physical distancing
  • Check temperatures of employees each day
  • Disinfect workplaces routinely
  • Ensure routine employee handwashing
  • Develop a COVID response plan and provide employee training
  • Adopt workplace policies necessary for implementing these requirements

More information on these requirements can be found below.

Background: On May 28, 2020, Gov. Jay Inslee issued Proclamation 20-57 concerning the health of agricultural workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. The intended purpose is to keep farmworkers safe from exposure to coronavirus. The proclamation requires agricultural employers, including dairies, to meet new worker safety requirements. By June 4, 2020, all agricultural employers must have the requirements in place or risk enforcement actions by the state. These requirements do not apply to meat or other food processing operations. They requirements will remain in effect for the duration of the state of emergency.

Documents: The proclamation can be found here. The list of new requirements is here.

Requirements: The proclamation lays out sanitation and PPE requirements for workers and employers. Please see the original proclamation and requirement documents for specifics. The key provisions are summarized below.

  • Personal Protective Equipment: Employers must provide PPE to employees at no cost to the employee. PPE means “face coverings, masks, respirators, gloves, and any other equipment needed to protect against hazards, including chemicals and COVID-19.” This list includes gloves, goggles, face shields, and face masks. PPE must be clean and available each workday. Cloth facial coverings must be worn by every employee not working alone on the job site.
  • Physical Distancing: Employers must ensure physical distancing of at least six feet between employees during all interactions of employment. When strict physical distancing is not feasible for a specific task, other prevention measures must be taken. Examples include more protective PPE, barriers, and negative pressure ventilation.
  • Workplace Disinfection: Employers must ensure high-touch surfaces are disinfected prior to the start of the workday and before and after all breaks. For night shifts, the same frequency of disinfecting is required. For dairies with shift workers, this would mean disinfecting before each shift.
  • Providing Handwashing Stations: Employers must supply adequate handwashing stations at every location and at all times that employees are working. All stations must have soap, tepid water, disposable paper towels, and a trash can. Hand sanitizer is not an adequate substitute for handwashing stations, but it must be provided in high-traffic locations where a handwashing station is impractical.
  • Using Handwashing Stations: Employers “must put in place adequate measures to ensure, at a minimum, that employees wash their hands for more than 20 seconds at the following intervals”: Arrival and departure from the worksite and prior to and after the first rest break, meal break, and second rest break.
  • Training: Employers must provide training to employees regarding COVID-19. This training includes required posters and safety protocols. The requirements include very specific minimum standards. See pages 3 and 4 of the requirements for that information.
  • COVID-19 Response Plan: Employers must have and maintain a COVID-19 response plan. The plan must be available to all employees. The plan must include specific items such as procedures for disinfecting areas where a symptomatic employee was present, notice to employees who were possibly exposed to COVID-19, and notice of employee rights and benefits. These items are covered in more detail on page 4 of the requirements.
  • Temperature Checks: At the beginning of each day, employers must conduct temperature checks of and review the symptom checklist with employees concerning themselves and their households. If an employee’s temperature is above 100.4 degrees, that employee has a fever and should be sent home. Thermometers must be properly sanitized between each use or each day.
  • Testing: “To the extent feasible, employers must ensure timely access to COVID-19 tests for symptomatic employees and must provide transportation as needed. Employers must designate a person or person who will be readily identifiable as the testing facilitators.”
  • Best Practices: Employers must stay up to date with guidance issued by the CDC, L&I, and DOH and should make every effort to implement all best practices to further protect employees.
  • Employee Rights: An employee may refuse to perform unsafe work, and it is unlawful for an employer to take adverse action against such an employee. Such employees may have access to certain leave and unemployment benefits.
  • Other Health Requirements: Employers must comply with all requirements of WAC 246-101 (communicable diseases) and any orders issued by local health jurisdictions.

In addition, the requirements spell out more details for outdoor worksites, indoor worksites, employer-provided transportation, and temporary worker housing. Dairy farms will have particular interest in the indoor worksite rules. For these sites, employers are required to implement a physical distancing plan, which must describe the ways in which a minimum of six feet of distancing will be achieved in all circumstances. For tasks where six feet of distancing is not feasible, the plan must describe the physical barriers used, negative pressure ventilation used, the higher level of PPE provided and used, and the administrative controls used to reduce interactions. Employers must ensure that tools, implements, and other equipment not be shared without being fully wipe-sanitized between uses.

Suggestions for Implementation:

  • Adopt policies implementing these new requirements. Train employees to them and have employees sign the new policies.
  • Document as much as possible. In case of an audit, inspection, and/or enforcement by a state agency, you will want and need to show what steps you have taken to protect employee safety.
  • Contact WSDF, other agricultural trade associations, and/or your co-op field representative with questions. Use L&I’s consultation services for assistance on this and other workplace safety issues.
  • The Dairy Federation has cloth masks that we can provide to you free. Contact us at 360.482.3485 or by emailing dan@wastatedairy.com
  • Washington Farm Bureau has hand sanitizer available to agricultural employers for free. Contact WFB at 360.357.9975.

COVID-19 Resources: Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act

This week the House of Representatives passed, and the President has now signed, the historic $2 trillion stimulus package dubbed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES), capping another wild week in Washington to help revive the U.S. economy and provide resources to many affected sectors, including dairy farmers.

The CARES Act, which the Senate approved on Wednesday, will deliver the largest-ever infusion of government money into the economy, both on a dollar and a percentage basis.

Agriculture Producer Disaster Assistance – The bill includes $9.5 billion to assist agriculture producers impacted by the coronavirus, including specialty crop producers; producers who support local food systems such as farmers markets, schools, and restaurants; and livestock and dairy producers.

 

COVID-19 Resources: Families First Coronavirus Response Act

On March 18, 2020, Congress passed and the President signed into law HR 6201, the Families First Coronavirus Response Act, a broad-ranging response to the COVID-19 outbreak.

HR 6201 temporarily expands the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) to provide paid leave for employees unable to work due to closure of schools and child-care facilities. The act also provides temporary paid sick leave for COVID-19-related absences. HR 6201 will become effective April 2, 2020.

These changes will impact your employment practices. All employers should re-evaluate their leave policies and prepare to implement these new requirements. In particular, notice must be given to employees. See the information and posters below for more information.

You can find the federal act here.

U.S. Department of Labor Information

Notices/Posters: Each covered employer must post a notice of the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) requirements in a conspicuous place on its premises. An employer may satisfy this requirement by emailing or direct mailing this notice to employees, or posting this notice on an employee information internal or external website. These provisions apply starting April 1, 2020, and continue through December 31, 2020.

Legal Resources: For more information, including detailed breakdowns of what is in the act and what must be complied with, see the legal resources below.